Sigh… I think I’ve said it a million times (cue whining music) why are things so much harder with REAL parenting?!?!?!? Discipline has got to be in the top 5, right up there with potty training and sleep training. But the WORST thing about discipline is that unlike sleep training and potty training, you are pretty much needing to get your act together until your child is a voter/driver/legal-aged drinker! I grew up with the old-fashioned discipline of fear and in some cases pain, or fear of pain (via spanking or pinching – ow!) Yet here I stand – an adult with two children and although I (think) I grew up to become a (relatively?) good and responsible human being – I can’t bring myself to physically discipline my children – it just doesn’t work for me mentally – and happily my husband is the same way. Our hands do clench into painful claws sometimes, but that’s pretty much it.
I never quite understood why it didn’t make sense for me. I’m not one to say its an ethical or moral thing. I don’t think my parents were abusive or unloving in any way. Then I attended a talk by Dr. Robert Brooks, and someone in the audience asked him a question about corporal punishment and he was adamantly against it – I found his reasoning quite perfect – (this isn’t verbatim by the way) what he said was that physical discipline does nothing for the child because it starts a bad cycle of wrongdoing and punishment (from a person of authority), what we should be aiming for is self-discipline – a child that knows he/she is doing wrong and corrects themselves. Yeah, I know — but it makes sense, especially when you see yourself correcting the same thing over and over again – your child won’t have you to correct them all day everyday for the rest of their lives. It is actually harder to discipline the non-corporal punishment way to be honest — we rely on a mixture of tough consequences and hopeful understanding of the cause. Dr. Brooks has a couple of very in-depth articles on spanking online – one is Perspectives on Discipline: Does Spanking Really Have a Role? Here is an excerpt —
First, a reminder about the meaning of discipline. We must not forget that the word discipline stems from the word disciple and is best conceived of as a teaching process. As a form of education, discipline should not be linked to so-called teaching practices that serve to humiliate, scare, or embarrass children…
What I consider to be another major function of discipline is to reinforce the development of self-discipline or self-control. Daniel Goleman, author of “Emotional Intelligence,” views self-discipline as one of the crucial components of emotional intelligence, a component that serves as a source of satisfying interpersonal relationships and success in various facets of one’s life. Self-discipline implies that a child has incorporated rules so that even when a parent or other adult is not present, the child will act in a thoughtful, considerate fashion. Self-discipline may be viewed as learning to take responsibility for one’s own behavior. Most of us do not want to be with other adults who lack self-discipline and are constantly yelling, shouting, saying hurtful things, jumping to conclusions, or blaming others.
Parents Magazine had an excellent article on ‘Guilt Free’ parenting – the article goes through both pitfalls and solutions in disciplining your kid/s. It is one of the ironies of parenting – you know you have to discipline your kids – yet there is guilt involved – mostly we are hard-wired to seeing our kids happy – so seeing unhappiness even for their own good does bring out the guilt (unless you are one of those hard-core military parents, which unfortunately we are not). In our case, for the most part our oldest daughter is really pretty ‘good’ SO when we do need to discipline her there is always that niggling feeling of being ‘tough’ on her since she is so often such a well behaved girl… (ugh, we are certifiable really) – so I do relate with the title of this article. Sometimes parenting too much from your heart messes with your brain ;0)
Let Go of the Guilt!
Parents today are obsessed with being “perfect,” says Jodi Stoner, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist and coauthor of Good Manners Are Contagious. “Parents are under so much stress these days, working long hours and spending more time out of the house,” she says. “When Mom and Dad are home, they want to spend quality time with the kids, and when they have to take time out to discipline, they feel guilty.” And that’s a dangerous emotion, says Kevin Leman, Ph.D., a family psychologist and author of Have a New Kid by Friday. “Guilt is the propellant for most of the bad decisions parents make. As a result, today’s kids are all about ‘me, me, me,’ and ‘gimme.’ They are held accountable less and less and have fewer responsibilities in the family. Fewer children today consider others before themselves because they’ve never been taught to think that way.” No wonder experts agree: Discipline is key.Create a Blueprint for Discipline
The Problem: One parent wants to be “the fun one,” which leaves the other parent in charge of discipline — and always feeling like “the bad guy.”
Mom and Dad are a team, and it’s essential that they’re on the same page when it comes to discipline, Dr. Stoner says. “You should not try to discipline in the moment. Punishments and rewards should have a rhyme and reason to them,” she says. “Sit down and discuss what values you want to give to your children. How will you teach good manners and proper behavior? What bothers one parent might not bother the other, so you need to come up with some clear rules — no hitting, no talking back, etc. — and consequences for breaking them. And both parents need to take responsibility for disciplining the kids.”Understand Your Job
The Problem: You feel like you’re constantly saying no to your child.
“Saying no 100 times a day is part of being a parent,” says Tom Phelan, Ph.D, a clinical psychologist and author of 1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12. “Once you accept that, you won’t feel as if you’re doing something wrong and guilt won’t be a factor.” However, you can use other methods of discipline besides the big N-O. For example, if your child asks to watch TV, you can answer with “Sure — after you’ve picked up your toys.” Here, you’re actually saying yes to the request, but with a stipulation.Give Yourself a Time-Out
The Problem: You sometimes start yelling when the kids misbehave, then feel awful about it afterward.
It can be easy to lose your patience with your kids, but once you start screaming and yelling, you’re taking the situation to a whole new level and have sent the message you’re no longer in control. “It’s impossible to discipline effectively when you’re angry or stressed out,” says Rex Forehand, Ph.D., a child behavior expert and coauthor of Parenting the Strong-Willed Child. Instead, he suggests implementing the four Rs. “You need to Recognize that you’ve lost patience, and Remove yourself from the situation,” Dr. Forehand says. “Once you’ve cooled down a bit, you can then Review the situation and Respond to it.”Ignore Your Child’s Bad Behavior
The Problem: Your child has tantrums in the supermarket, toy store, etc. — and nothing you do can make it better.
First, let’s make one thing clear: Every parent has had to handle a child’s public tantrum. Still, it’s tough to remember that when it feels as if all eyes are on you. The worst thing to do is engage a child in the middle of a meltdown. Yelling or attempting to compromise or reason with her will only make the tantrum worse and increase your stress levels. The best way to tackle a tantrum is to ignore it, Dr. Leman says. “When your child is throwing a tantrum, the purpose is to get attention and to exert authority over you. And if throwing tantrums has worked in the past, your child will continue to throw them in the future.” Dr. Leman’s suggestion is to step over the child, totally ignore the behavior, and move on with whatever else you were doing. Nine times out of 10, your child will get up and follow you. If you’re in public, don’t be so worried about what other people will think — this is about nipping this bad behavior in the bud.Don’t Feel the Need to Explain Everything
The Problem: From putting his coat on before you leave the house and getting into the car seat, to eating his veggies and taking a bath, everything with your child feels like a battle.
“Why” is a child’s favorite question. Children of all ages love to use oppositional behavior to test their limits. Parents often make the mistake of trying to reason with their child when she’s misbehaving, which usually leads to more arguing. Instead of getting into a debate that will eventually lead to tears (sometimes for both of you), offer her a firm — and nonnegotiable — reason for why she needs to do what you’re telling her. If she does something that can hurt her or another child, simply say: “We don’t do this — it’s dangerous.” When she throws her toys: “We don’t throw toys. It’s time to put them away.” If she doesn’t want to be strapped into her car seat: “It’s the law, so you need to sit in your car seat or we are not going anywhere.” “Don’t banter back and forth with your child,” Dr. Phelan says. “You’ve made your decision and you’re done.”Be Consistent
The Problem: You know you shouldn’t, but you sometimes let bad behavior slide to avoid a confrontation.
Your little one has decided to empty all of his toy bins onto the living room floor. He usually gets a time-out for this behavior, but it’s the end of the day and you’re beat. It’s okay to let him get away with it just this one time, right? Wrong, Dr. Stoner says. Letting it go sends the message that this behavior is okay, so you have no one to blame but yourself when your child drives you crazy with it later on. “There has to be a consequence every time a child does something he shouldn’t. You can’t do it sometimes and not others. Initially, it’s a lot of work for the parents, but it pays off in the long run.”Practice Encouragement, Not Praise
The Problem: Your child expects a reward every time she behaves.
According to Dr. Leman, there is a big difference between encouragement and praise. For example, you come home one afternoon to find that your daughter has washed the breakfast dishes without being asked. Your response: “You’re the best little girl in the whole world! You get $5 for being such a good kid!” That’s praise — and it sets up a pattern of entitlement and expectations that can follow your child throughout her life. Encouragement would be: “That was such a thoughtful thing to do! Thank you!” Part of a parent’s job is to make sure each child gives back to the family in some way, Dr. Leman says. “They shouldn’t expect a reward for it.”Don’t Forget to Have Fun!
The Problem: You’re worried your kids see you as “mean Mommy.”
Discipline doesn’t have to be a constant drag, Dr. Phelan says. You can enforce rules in a fun way by using some creativity. For example, if your kids have a hard time focusing on homework when they get home from school, make a game out of it. “Set the kitchen timer and tell them the goal is to finish their work before it goes off,” Dr. Phelan says. You can do the same when it comes to brushing teeth, getting dressed in the morning, or cleaning bedrooms. Or set up a chart in the kitchen where your kids can check off their assignments and chores when they’re done — kids love to see visual reminders of what they’ve accomplished!
Originally published in the June 2010 issue of Parents magazine.
http://www.parents.comBringing together the power of respected magazine brands including American Baby and Parents, the Parents Network is your go-to destination for parenting information. From first kicks to first steps and on to the first day of school, we are here to help you celebrate the joys and navigate the challenges of parenthood.
- Toddler Discipline: Effective and Appropriate Tactics (webmd.com)
- Preschoolers: Tips for Discipline and Manners (webmd.com)
- The Long-Term Effects of Spanking (theatlantic.com)
- How Spanking Harms the Brain (psychologytoday.com)
- National Spank Out Day – Positive Discipline Resources (attachmentparenting.org)
- Physical discipline linked to future aggression (ctv.ca)
- With Spanking, Nature and Nurture Create More Aggression, Study Suggests (nlm.nih.gov)